retail Cartoons

Happy (Product) Returns

Product Returns cartoon

“Free Returns” has become the new “Free Shipping,” which is creating a massive logistical headache for retailers, particularly in the weeks after Christmas.   This year, shoppers in the US returned 14.5% of the items they purchased, valued at $743 billion.  That’s nearly double the return rates of pre-pandemic 2019.  One third of shoppers now make returns part of their shopping strategy, buying multiple items, knowing they’ll return some later. As Gartner retail analyst Tom Enright put it in the WSJ a few days ago, “we’re headed for a trillion dollar problem here.” The economics of product returns are brutal.  […]

holiday deal creep

Holiday Deal Creep cartoon

Black Friday has long shed its American Thanksgiving roots, spreading around the world, spanning more of the calendar, and pulling in more brands and retailers.  Black Friday has morphed into Black November and Cyber Monday has expanded into Cyber Week. As Marshall Cohen of the NPD Group put it: “Black Friday used to be the greatest day in retail all year. Now it’s becoming background noise … It’s not actually Black Friday anymore, or even Black Friday weekend or Black Friday week. It some cases it started in October. Lowe’s and Home Depot even had Spring Black Friday sales… “Christmas […]

marketing at the point of sale

“You go to the drug store now, you buy one or two things, you get a receipt that’s like a Miss America sash,” Jimmy Kimmel joked a couple years ago. E-receipts may be on the rise, but many retailers are still cranking out massive paper receipts at the till. Adweek performed an experiment with eight national retailers in the US. They bought a pack of Trident spearmint gum and measured the length of the paper receipt. The winner was Kmart with a receipt clocking in at two feet. That included a rewards membership pitch, a pitch to take a survey, […]

the future of e-commerce

Voice is starting to redefine how consumers buy brands. Brands will increasingly have to navigate a world that doesn’t have a traditional user interface — zero UI. As Google CEO Sundar Pichai put it, “we will move from mobile first to an AI first world.” Walker Sands recently reported that one in five (19%) have made a voice purchase through Amazon Echo or similar device and another third (33%) plan to do so in the next year. According to ComScore, 50% of all searches will be voice searches by 2020. Amazon is leading much of this charge. 84% of consumers […]

Join 50,000 others and get a new marketoon and my insights delivered to your inbox weekly.

The signup form could not load. Subscribe here instead.

retail in the age of amazon

“In the age of Amazon, retailers must leverage assets that Bezos doesn’t have: When Amazon zigs, retails must zag.” This was a quote from NYU Stern professor Scott Galloway in a Fast Company report this week on “The Future of Retail in the Age of Amazon.” Some analysts are calling this era a retail apocalypse. In the US this year, 8600 stores shuttered and Credit Suisse predicts that a quarter of all malls in the US will close in the next five years. Amazon currently makes up 5% of total US retail sales and in the next five years will […]

Christmas creep

It’s only a matter of time before holiday deals start lapping themselves. Last year, Target kicked off the Christmas shopping season with a holiday ad on October 7th, 79 days before Christmas and 3 weeks before Halloween. This year, Kmart upped the ante with a holiday ad on September 10th, 105 days before Christmas and right in the midst of back-to-school. Increasingly retailers are embracing Christmas Creep. This year’s pressure intensified in the US with six fewer selling days between Thanksgiving and Christmas. Black Friday started a week early for Walmart and many retailers started deals in the midst of […]

loyalty programs

Marketers often confuse loyalty with getting consumers to carry one more plastic card in a wallet already filled with plastic loyalty cards. I experienced this cartoon a few weeks ago at an Office Depot in Colorado. The one and only cashier leisurely chatted up every customer with the same up-sell pitch (loyalty points, extended warranties, impulse items at the till), even as a line of customers grumbled about how long it was taking and thinking it would have been easier to shop online. When everyone offers a similar “loyalty” program, has loyalty lost its meaning? Particularly when loyalty seems primarily […]

mobile is the new end cap

Last week I spoke at Signal P&G, an event put on by P&G and Federated Media that brought a variety of tech thinkers (from Google, Facebook, Pinterest, Twitter, etc.) to the birth place of brand management to talk about the future of marketing. Margo Georgiadis from Google shared an insight that struck me in particular: “mobile is the new end cap“. It reminded me of a concept I’d once heard from another Googler, Jim Lecinski, about the “Zero Moment of Truth” (available as an ebook). A.G. Lafley from P&G famously coined the “First Moment of Truth” as the 3-7 seconds […]

showrooming

One of the biggest threats to traditional retail is “showrooming”, where consumers check out products in a store, but then go online to buy. Mobile devices have made prices fully transparent to everyone. Since traditional retailers carry higher overhead than online retailers, it’s a real marketing challenge. Do retailers drop their prices and cut their margins, or do they find a way to justify the premium versus online? Many retailers opt to drop their prices. Electronics chain Best Buy first tried to make it harder to comparison-shop by changing their in-store bar codes. When that didn’t work, they tried to […]

holiday advertising

It’s beginning to look a lot like Christmas, and it’s not even Halloween. Many retailers like Restoration Hardware are already decorating for the winter holidays. Target even aired a Christmas TV ad on October 14, three weeks before Halloween and six weeks before Thanksgiving. The Target voice-over announces, “The holidays are coming and they’re gonna be big”. One consumer replied to Target’s ad in social media: “Hey Target….can I at least finish trick or treating before I get bombarded with Christmas?” Is the accelerated timing consumer-centric or retailer-centric? Is it driven by actual consumer shopping behavior or competitive one-upmanship? “Christmas […]

product proliferation

Some brands are line extension machines. To jockey for shelf space, they launch waves of new SKUs each year, often without meaningful differentiation from what is already there. I’m sure there are category management justifications for every niche item, but most supermarket shelves are cluttered and hard to shop. Does Crest really need 40 varieties of toothpaste? Clutter causes confusion and confusion causes paralysis. I love the refreshing simplicity of Help Remedies. I first spotted the healthcare brand at Duane Reade a couple years ago. Against the clutter of a typical drugstore aisle, they stand out. Help’s rally cry campaign […]

the last mile

The “last mile” is usually thought of as a supply chain challenge: how to best deliver products the final leg to individual customers. Yet the last mile is also a marketing challenge. The last mile for you is the first mile for your consumers. The shelf is where many consumers discover your product, and where most purchase decisions are made. How your product appear on that shelf (either physical or virtual) matters. In the real world, our products never look as amazing as they do in our offices. In the real world, our products sit on dusty Kroger bottom shelves […]

evolution of retail

  I was fortunate to hear Seth Godin give a talk in London this last week. He led a packed room through a whirlwind tour of his ideas on marketing, business, and leadership at large. This cartoon was inspired by something Seth covered early in the talk. He put up a few slides with photos from his local grocery store, including a massive 16-foot section with nothing but tofu. He asked the audience, "remember when tofu just came in 2 varieties? Plain and extra plain?" The level of choice proliferation in the last decade is staggering. So much new product […]

shopping support group

  This week, I'm chairing a conference put on by Marketing magazine on marketing in the credit crunch .  They've invited an interesting roster of speakers, including people from McDonalds, Lush, innocent, and my friend Jon Rudoe at Ocado.  A good mix of retailers and manufacturers from companies large and small, and promotion-driven to more premium. I'll post some of my takeaways after the day.  If any of you have any questions you'd like me to pose the speakers during the conference, post them as a comment to this blog by Monday afternoon and I'll add them to the Q&A after each […]

the 8 types of retail buyers

(A quick groveling note to any retail buyers I work with who may be reading: this cartoon was entirely inspired by anecdotes from other people (my competitors actually).  So, please, please, pretty please don't discontinue my products.  OK, Partner?) Now that the fearful groveling is out of the way, I've been thinking a lot about retail in the context of the credit crunch lately.  Consumers are obviously looking to brands and retailers for solutions. This is tough, because I'd classify many retailer/manufacturer "relationships" as transactional, not really relationships at all.  And those transactions can be pretty combative.  It's often centered […]

pavlov's promotions

With the credit crunch brewing, there’s a lot of pressure to ramp up your price promotions.  There certainly is a short-term argument (sales are down, consumers are increasingly price-sensitive, and price promotions are a predictable way to drive volume).  But, in the long-run, I think it can start to train your consumers to only buy you on deal (like the Pavlovian response in this cartoon). It reminds me of my time on Haagen-Dazs.  Years ago, Haagen-Dazs and Ben & Jerry’s had a good thing going.  They co-existed peacefully (promotion-wise), rarely promoting like the less premium ice cream brands in the […]

dance of the retail partners

I’ve been involved in some kooky one-sided retailer negotiations lately, including thorny topics like exclusivity.  The retail market is more concentrated in the UK than in the US, so it’s pretty clear where the power lies here.  But, I think the basic dynamic holds true in the US too.  Of course, in this one-sided dynamic, it takes extra creativity (and fast two-stepping) to turn it into something like a partnership.  Instead of submitting to pressure, it’s possible to create something unique and powerful even when you’re much, much smaller than the retailer. And then, last night, my daughter’s school hosted […]

inside retail partnerships

Obviously, not all retail partnerships work like this.  But, I do feel like the typical starting point can be pretty adversarial.  And the balance of power is definitely with the retailer. I was in a retail meeting recently, and the category director explained how they tier the meeting rooms.  "The little ones by the lobby are for people we don’t like, the ones in the main floor are for people we like OK, and we never, ever bring suppliers up to our floor.  I don’t even want them to know what I think."  Fortunately, we weren’t meeting in the lobby […]