management Cartoons

return on indecision

I spent a few days in Vermont last week with Eureka Ranch founder, Doug Hall. At one point, Doug said, “if you’re not meaningfully unique, you better be cheap”. Any idea that is “meaningfully unique” is inherently risky because by definition you can’t point to a precedent in the market. You have to step into the unknown, which is uncomfortable. When many companies are faced with the unknown, they freeze. They spend hours debating potential scenarios and are incapable of making the go/no go decision. Sometimes this indecisive period lasts months or longer. One of my previous managers was king […]

your call is very important

I sketched this cartoon while on hold with United Airlines last week. I spent a total of two hours and 12 minutes with United over four separate phone calls trying to get home from New York after the storm, so I had a lot of time to think about service. Many brands fall down on service. They view it as a cost center. Yet, all the marketing dollars invested in animated TV ads and direct mail mail pieces can be evaporated by a couple bad service experiences. Marketers dream of having a captive consumer audience. Most brands struggle for attention. […]

mission statement

There’s an interesting disagreement between Jim Stengel and Simon Clift, former CMOs of P&G and Unilever: “Who is Right: P&G or Unilever?“. Jim is in the process of writing a book and teaching a UCLA class on the role of purpose and ideals in business. He invited Simon Clift to talk to students last week and probed on the different ideals of two different Unilever brands. Jim asked Simon how he felt about “the juxtaposition of Dove’s Brand Ideal of improving women’s self esteem with Axe/Lynx’s Ideal of helping geeky guys get the girl, with a “tongue-in-cheek” sexist portrayal of […]

blamestorming

Many organizations are better at blamestorming than brainstorming. It is far easier to critique than to create. No one wants to end up on the wall of failure. Blamestorming not only hampers big ideas. It creates a debilitating cycle of pointing the finger. Sales blames Marketing. Marketing blames R&D. R&D blames Operations. Operations blames Sales. Around it goes. Even thinking of your team as functional silos, rather than individuals, reinforces this blame game. The result is that the next project inherits the tension and baggage from the previous one.  It becomes ever more difficult to try something new. It is […]

Join 50,000 others and get a new marketoon and my insights delivered to your inbox weekly.

The signup form could not load. Subscribe here instead.

monetize it

“Monetize” is one of the top 10 buzz words for 2010. Many businesses are retooling their business models and figuring out new revenue streams. Last week, I spent a few thought-stirring days in Portland at a publishing workshop organized by Todd Sattersten. We talked about the future of publishing, which is in the middle of epic change. The workshop offered innumerable lessons, not only for publishing, but for any form of marketing. I learned there were 11,000 new business books launched last year alone, which hints at the odds of breaking through the clutter in a book store. Launching a […]

waterfall planning

waterfall planning

Crafting an annual plan is like getting a bill through Congress. Behind the final numbers and strategies lie countless hours of spreadsheet crunching, hallway meetings, and waterfall charts. We debate assumptions, broker compromises, and eventually settle on a plan that is wrong the moment it’s inked. A finance director once told me that “spending more time on planning won’t make the numbers more accurate; it just makes the numbers wrong to the penny.” It’s important to know the business inside and out and have a clear trajectory where we’re headed.  But there is a point where planning becomes overplanning.  All […]

the 8 types of managers

the 8 types of managers

I recently heard someone referred to as a “seagull manager”, a term Ken Blanchard coined in 1985: “seagull managers fly in, make a lot of noise, dump on everyone, then fly out.” This conversation prompted a discussion on bad managers of all stripes. Everyone at the table had a top-of-mind example. I grouped some of the most common offenders into this cartoon. If bad management is so readily visible, why are their so many culprits? Part of it I think is that many managers are oblivious to their impact on others. One of my friends quit a job specifically because […]

idea prevention department

100913.ideaprevention.jpg

I recently heard someone refer to their legal department as a “Sales Prevention Department”. I realized that most businesses have some sort of “idea prevention department”, whether they nickname it the “VP of We Can’t” or the “Abominable No Men”. These are the alarmists who are so focused on what can go wrong that they miss the big picture. When every risk is magnified with a telephoto lens, it sometimes feels safer to stand still. When you are championing an idea in an organization, you have to win over the “Abominable No Men”. Some of this comes through asking for […]

the art of planning

100830.artofplanning.jpg

For many businesses, planning for 2011 is in full swing, particularly the horse-trading, haggling, and negotiating to choose the revenue target. The core business team develops a bottoms-up plan they feel is achievable. The leadership team sets an top-down stretch target that is much higher. Then everyone bickers over the gap between the two numbers. There are a few schools of thought on where to draw the line in between. Set your target too low and you can reliably hit the number, but you may not have achieved anything remarkable. Set your target too high and it may spur you […]

devil’s advocate

100719.devilsadvocate

I’ve been hooked this week by Seth Godin’s latest book, Linchpin. Seth briefly profiles the Devil’s Advocate, which he describes as a “card-carrying member of the Resistance” — a force that prevents remarkable ideas from coming to life. In his blog, Seth occasionally advises his readers to “uninvite the devil’s advocate, since the devil doesn’t need one, he’s doing fine.” The Devil’s Advocate is a regular staffer in most offices. “Let me play Devil’s Advocate” is a socially acceptable way to shoot down an idea. It’s a guise that allows anyone to criticize an idea without offering an alternative. It’s […]

shiny new thing

100524.shiny_.jpg

ADHD isn’t just for teenagers. It afflicts businesses and teams too. I once heard a venture capitalist offer to prescribe Ritalin to one of his portfolio companies. It’s easy to get distracted by the Shiny New Thing. It’s particularly easy to get distracted when the going gets tough on your core plan and energy starts to wane. Whether it’s a new technology, a new product, or a new customer, falling in love with the Shiny New Thing can take a team off course. It’s easy to get enthusiastic about the promise of something new than the hard slog of what you’re […]

iProcrastinate

100322.iprocrastinate.jpg

Last week, I happened across Tim Ferriss handing out copies of 4-Four Hour Workweek at SXSW. I first read the book two years ago after hearing Tim speak at the Do Lectures in Wales. We were the only two Americans there and I was inspired by his talk. I reread some of the book on the flight home and was struck by story of Vilfredo Pareto and the discovery of the famous 80/20 Principle: 80% of the outputs result from 20% of the inputs. Tim relates Pareto to our work life by contrasting Being Effective from Being Efficient: Being busy […]

communication etiquette

I was struck by a recent Joel Spolsky column in Inc. magazine on dysfunctional communication in growing companies. “What used to work with three people in a garage all talking to one another about everything just doesn’t work when your head count reaches 10 or 20 people. Everybody who doesn’t need to be in that meeting is killing productivity.” Joel goes further by describing Brook’s Law: “Adding people to a late project tends to make it run later still.” This counter-intuitive observation highlights a serious business problem: well-intended over-communication. Each additional person needed to keep in the loop exponentially slows […]

definition of insanity

I’ve always liked the Albert Einstein quote, “The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results.” I recently started following the witting observations of @MeetingBoy (“Say or do something stupid in a meeting and I’ll tweet it”).  He’s putting out a 2010 MeetingBoy calendar in the next week or so and asked if I’d create a cartoon to illustrate one of his tweets. So, this cartoon is based on one that I liked the most: “Definition of insanity: holding the same meeting with the same people every week and expecting different results.” Last […]

business day care

We had a dinner party Friday for some friends moving away from London, and one of them described his job as “adult day care”.  He spends a lot of time getting his team to “play nice”. This expression cracked me up and reminded me of the Robert Fulghum essay, “all I really need to know, I learned in kindergarten.”  I think this applies to what we need to know in business too. A lot of organizations get caught up in turf wars and bickering silos.  This only seems to get worse when there’s the pressure we’re all feeling in this economic […]

silo farming

I’ve been reading a book on Steve Jobs called “Inside Steve’s Brain” by Leander Kahney.  Really interesting distillation of some of the Apple magic. I was struck by the product development process, which is cross-functional in the extreme, with designers, engineers, marketers, and programmers all involved early and in a very connected way. The book contrasted this with a typical step-by-step design process, where products are passed from one team to the next, and there’s little back and forth between the departments. It all got me thinking of the problems caused by rifts between deep functional silos, and prompted this […]

little miss corporate

For father’s day, my girls gave me a bright yellow t-shirt that says "Mr. Perfect."  I felt pretty darn special.  The next day, I took them to the park and saw a couple guys wearing "Mr. Perfect" t-shirts.  "Wait a minute," I thought defensively, "I thought I was Mr. Perfect." Suddenly, I started noticing the Mr. Men / Little Miss shirts all over the place, proclaiming all sorts of personality traits: grumpy, happy, naughty, etc.  It made me think of the corporate world, where there is a whole other set of personality traits.  So, I thought I’d put a few […]

the organizational bullwhip

In business school, I once joined an exercise called "the beer game".  Not quite as fun as it sounds, but interesting.  Our class piled into a computer simulation lab, and we acted out parts of a brewery supply chain.  We weren’t allowed to talk to each other.  We could only place orders and fulfill orders for our part of the supply chain.  You had to guess demand based on the orders coming in.  Everybody else was also guessing, and you tended to overreact.  So, someone overreacting a little at the beginning of the supply chain created a ripple effect that […]

truth in labeling

I love going to factories.  Putting on the hard hat and lab coat and seeing where the magic happens.  It makes me feel like Willy Wonka.  Massive humming machines.  Thousands of containers whizzing by on conveyer belts.  Ice cream plants are particularly cool. But, the inner workings of a plant always seem like a stark contrast from the persona put across on the label.  Particularly if the brand has any kind of provenance.  Ingredients just don’t look as premium when you see them in jumbo totes.  The "family recipe" doesn’t seem so homey when it’s being blended by a guy […]

the five stages of missing plan

To everyone at work, I promise I’m not signalling anything with this cartoon (I’m confident we’ll make it all up by Q4). I was thinking of the funny dance we all do in "meeting plan" (hitting your volume targets). Whenever you’re off, the easiest thing to do is blame the plan itself and whoever committed to it in the first place (which is particularly funny when it was you).  There’s a lot of nuance around timing and when and how to communicate that you’re off plan.  The process reminded me of Kübler-Ross’ "Five Stages of Grief".  I first riffed on […]