There’s nothing spookier this Halloween than some of the headlines. Sapio Research recently found that a whopping 95% of global businesses are concerned about a potential recession, with 45% of US businesses “highly concerned.” Fear can drive a knee-jerk response in a recessionary environment to cut, cut, cut — marketing budgets, media spend, hiring, headcount, R&D investment. In 2010, Harvard Business Review published one of the most in-depth studies on how businesses historically operate in a recession. Ranjay Gulati, Nitin Nohria and Franz Wohlgezogen studied 4,700 public companies before, during, and after various recessions to analyze the choices they made […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
A few years ago, a yogurt brand increased its margin by putting less yogurt in every container while keeping the same retail price. So that the products wouldn’t look smaller, they kept the same packaging, which meant that every container suddenly had several inches of air at the top of the yogurt. To justify this obvious drop in value, they added a package burst that said, “Now Room For Your Favorite Mix-ins!” They tried (unsuccessfully) to make the fact that they were short-selling product into a consumer benefit. There is constant pressure in business to improve margins through cost-cutting. This […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
It’s beginning to look a lot like January, even with nearly a week left until Christmas. Retailers started post-Christmas markdowns extra early this year. Deloitte analyst Jason Gordon explained it this way: “There’s a finite amount of spend. If one of your big rivals goes on Sale, you don’t have any choice. You’ve got to get your share of the action, otherwise it’ll go to your competitor and be lost. It’s a game of chicken and there’s only going to be one winner – the consumer.” Of course heavy discounting carries a price, particularly the time of year when retailers […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
I’ve been thinking about how consumers are spending (or not spending) in this environment. With wallets under lock-and-key, one might think that a premium brand wouldn’t have much of a chance. This is a time when consumers are evaluating where their money goes. With low consumer confidence, there is less that is being spent in general. What is being spent is carefully considered. Yet Apple still managed to blow away iPhone expectations this last quarter. Even in the midst of a recession. And value-oriented attack ads from Microsoft. I know, I know, Apple is the stereotypical poster brand. It’s almost […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
I came across a Brandweek article called "Enough with the Value Messages Already" and it made me think of the song-and-dance that many businesses are doing to demonstrate value nowadays. The primary knee-jerk reaction for brands in the recession has been to radically drop price (either permanently or through deep discounting). With many retailers ramping up private label "switch and save" promotions, the pressure is even stronger. But this approach can create a lot of long-term damage and cheapen the brand. It's hard to ever unwind it once you're on that path. Others have adopted a platform reminding consumers what […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
I've been thinking about how the recession is sinking into the collective business psyche. It feels like we're all going through some form of the Kübler-Ross stages of grief (which I like using as a cartoon setup). I've been struck by the resurgence of WWII-era propaganda, like the vintage "Keep Calm and Carry On" poster that suddenly appeared everywhere. I've recently spotted the two clever parodies to the right. My favorite is "Get Excited & Make Things", created by Matt Jones. I like this message because it doesn't dwell on the sky falling, which feels so counter-productive. Instead, it focuses […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
I stumbled across "recession washing" as a useful expression in this presentation and thought it captured so much of the advertising bandwagon right now. Six months ago, I was at a conference on marketing in the credit crunch and several speakers stressed the importance of showing empathy to consumers. Of course, sincerity is crucial too. Empathy without sincerity can do more harm than good. The last two years, agencies were flooded with "green briefs". Many businesses tasked their agencies to come up with advertising to communicate sustainability (whether or not there was any actual substance there). This year, it feels […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
I think LinkedIn can be a meaningful tool. It just cracks me how many invitations we all get with the default "since you are a person I trust" greeting. Particularly when they come from people we don't actually know. A friend of mine who used to run a high profile investment fund told me he gets 20-30 LinkedIn requests a day. He's seen a noticeable surge in the last six months, which struck me that LinkedIn is probably a good barometer of the career anxiety we're all facing. So many of these interactions start and end with the LinkedIn invitation. […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
"Risk aversion, prudence and frugality – these are rational short-term responses to a serious global recession but will in the longer term make it much worse." This quote comes from an interesting management journal editorial that inspired this cartoon. From a Baroness no less. Like many of us, I've been playing armchair macro-economics lately. I've been struck by the economic concept of The Paradox of Thrift, which has been in hot debate over the last few months. Consumers are being pulled in both directions at once. As marketers, it's our job to find ways to increase demand (even in a […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
"What we're experiencing right now is a complete sea change requiring us to completely rethink what were doing. We need to think our way out of this recession, not just wait for it to get better." I read this quote from Michael Perman (Levi Strauss) in this AdAge article and thought it was spot-on (thanks to Don and Eliza for sharing it). It was just spark I needed to finish this cartoon. I had been sketching the general idea since I drew "blend into the herd" early this month, and this quote inspired the closer. This economic climate feels like […]
It's never easy to do business forecasting, but this year is a total mystery. Every forecast discussion seems to start with a conversation to agree how optimistic or pessimistic to be. It reminded me of the old "glass half full/glass half empty" test. Most of what I'm hearing is pretty pessimistic. And it's only a few weeks into January. In this kind of climate, what do we have to lose? It's a good year to take a gamble and try something new. If it's generally agreed that it's going to be a rough year, the "same-old, same-old" approach isn't going […]
I remember learning about "trading up" when I worked on the Häagen-Dazs brand a few years ago. Our VP was a big fan of the book Trading Up, which described how middle-market consumers felt affluent and were starting to trade up up higher premium products. We baked "trading up" into our brand strategy. Afterall, we weren't just a premium brand, we were a superpremium brand (ice cream is one of the few categories where superpremium is legally defined – fun fact for today). Not only was superpremium more profitable, it was growing. Consumers were willing to pay more for products […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
I originally started this cartoon as a series of panels on "recession survival tactics". I started thinking about different brands as "species" and I sketched a few panels with examples of how different brands approach the threat of recession: a turtle hiding in its protective shell, an ostrich with its head in the sand, etc. Then I started sketching a panel on "blending into the herd", and I realized this would be fun to draw as a full cartoon (I may draw the other "species" later). "Blending into the herd" feels like one of the most common responses to the recession. 2009 is […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
Value is of course the theme of the moment, and marketers are all scrambling to add more “value” into their marketing plans for 2009. I met with a retail buyer last week, and tried to convince her that there was still a role for premium brands in a recession. I shared my opinion that a recession simply heightens the urgency for premium brands to prove that they are meaningful enough to command a premium. The retail buyer disagreed. She said that premium brands had two and only two choices in this economic climate. Either increase price promotions to compensate for the premium […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
December is often a time of year when things quiet down for marketers (except for the spike in agency parties). But this year it feels dominated by a whole lot of scenario brainstorming and re-planning. The common theme is how to do “more with less”. I started kicking around cartoon ideas around “more with less” and the metaphor of a drought came to mind. While some brands with deep pockets will use this time to maintain spending and grow faster than less-funded competitors, most brands are facing budget cuts like they’ve never seen before. In a drought, it’s a good time to re-evaluate entirely what you’re […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
The nice people at the UK Marketing Society asked me to donate a cartoon for their Christmas card this year. So, I came up with this. As I kicked around a few ideas, I realized this cartoon would be particularly relevant this “Black Friday” weekend (the Friday after Thanksgiving in the US and the official start of the Christmas shopping season). Along with my cartoon, the UK Marketing Society is including an article from Google called “Speeding up in the slowdown”. I like that sentiment. It includes a quote that “history tells us that slowdowns are when winners get ahead. The […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
This week, I'm chairing a conference put on by Marketing magazine on marketing in the credit crunch . They've invited an interesting roster of speakers, including people from McDonalds, Lush, innocent, and my friend Jon Rudoe at Ocado. A good mix of retailers and manufacturers from companies large and small, and promotion-driven to more premium. I'll post some of my takeaways after the day. If any of you have any questions you'd like me to pose the speakers during the conference, post them as a comment to this blog by Monday afternoon and I'll add them to the Q&A after each […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
Nowadays, barely a day goes by without hearing the expression "cash is king". I started to wonder, if cash is king, what's the rest of the royal family? I knocked around this metaphor and my mind wandered to playing cards. It's clear that the game has changed, and the winning hand in a recession is going to be different than what worked before. It feels like everyone is scrambling to figure out how to play "Recession Hold-em". Sequoia Capital framed the new rules in a sobering presentation to their portfolio companies last month: "RIP: Good Times". It's depressing stuff, and […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
I spent a lot of time at the budget table this week, talking through cuts to 2009 spending. As we all debated the merits (and drawbacks) of every possible place to trim costs in our P&L, the image of a pork barbecue diagram suddenly popped into my head, and I scribbled this cartoon on the back of the P&L. All while nodding attentively to our supply chain goals for next year. Sorry, Andy. I suspect there are quite a few "budget cut barbecues" cooking at the moment. And with even more than the usual pressure to trim marketing investments in […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
I walked past plenty of Halloween decorations this weekend. But it struck me that the current newspaper headlines feel spookier than any of them. Instead of the same-old ghosts, skeletons, and witch costumes rampant on Halloween, I thought it would be fun to imagine a real fright night for anyone who works in marketing: kids dressed up as the credit crunch, consumer belt tightening, or your bonus up in flames. This is kind the same spirit as this Christmas cartoon I drew a couple years ago. No cartoon last week, in case you were searching. I was on holiday (our 10th wedding anniversary actually) and […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.