I heard somewhere years ago that the reason the classic TV remote control is so ridiculously complicated is that each button has its own product manager, lobbying hard for the features of that button. I think of that every time I stay in an Airbnb and can’t figure out how to turn on the TV. It inspired this cartoon. In 1967, a computer scientist named Melvin Conway introduced an idea that explains this phenomenon and system design in general. It eventually became known as Conway’s Law. In a piece titled “How Do Committees Invent?”, Conway observed that systems end up […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
The web has turned into an obstacle course of pop-ups upon pop-ups. No one likes pop-ups and yet there’s plenty of conversion data that designers can point at to justify them. That’s the pop-up conundrum. There’s data to show people find them annoying and there’s data to show they work. Pop-ups have become standard design practice, and yet I still find it strange that standard design practice would accept design that is “annoying but effective.” I think we have to be careful with the “annoying but effective” justification. The numbers sometimes ignore hidden costs like lower engagement. And there’s […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
User experience design often loses sight of the actual user. When sites optimize so much for the behavior that it wants to influence next (collecting an email address, moving people into a funnel), the reason that people come to the site in the first place can get overlooked (or buried under pop-ups). There’s a continual balancing act between user experience and user exploitation: what is best for the user and what is best for the company. A designer has to navigate that line. At one end of the spectrum, there’s been a lot of recent attention to “Dark UX“: “an […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
Sir Alec Issigonis, designer of the original Mini in 1959, famously said, “a camel is a horse designed by committee.” The Mini became one of the most successful cars of all time. Sir Alec was knighted is 1969 because of its success. The car was voted the second most influential car of the 20th century. The Mini became an icon largely because it didn’t fall prey to design by committee. Alex Issigonis wanted to create a small, simple, and economical car. He set size and fuel efficiency as the unwavering design criteria. The Mini featured a revolutionary front wheel drive […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
Instagram caught a lot of flak for its rebranding last week, but it’s only the most recent in a string of companies that have gone through brand makeovers. Uber, Airbnb, and Yahoo each debuted new brand identities in the last couple years that were widely lampooned. The biggest rebranding cautionary tales remain Tropicana in 2009, which backtracked after sales dropped by 20%, and Gap in 2010, which reverted to its old logo after just 6 days of criticism. What cracks me up the most about rebranding efforts is the self-indulgent way that brand teams can articulate what went into them. […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
Design Thinking is one of the more hyped (and frequently misunderstood) terms in business. Many companies have jumped on the Design Thinking bandwagon without really knowing what it means. The term is frequently trotted out to describe just about any organization — even organizations with a pretty superficial appreciation of Design. Sometimes the Design Thinking term gets confused with its props and artifacts. It can be easy to assume that all an organization needs to “do” Design Thinking is an offsite, a whiteboard, and a stack of sticky note pads. As a result, Design Thinking has lost much of its […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
If a brand has to shout that it’s “new and improved”, it’s probably not all that new or improved. “New and improved” is the easiest and lamest of marketing claims. Marketers use it to create new spin on an old brand, but it’s often not much more than label-deep. It’s the least interesting marketing lever to pull. I was struck by this quote from HBS Professor Youngme Moon’s classic book on marketing, “Different“: “In the 1960s and ’70s, the words “new and improved” really meant something to people; today, those same words don’t mean much at all … In category […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
How we review creative is as valuable a part of the creative process as the creative itself. Yet the creative review is often overlooked and frequently misunderstood. The most talented designers in the world will create mediocre work if the creative review process is managed in a mediocre way. I love the video that circulated a few years ago called “Microsoft Designs the iPod Package”. In several hysterically accurate minutes, the sleek Apple packaging design devolves into a cluttered mess because of creative feedback from the Microsoft marketing team. The fascinating epilogue is that it turns out the video was […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
How Draconian are your Brand Guidelines? Many brands focus so much on maintaining consistency that they forget one of the most important goals of Brand Guidelines — inspiring creative work. Building a brand takes a village, inside the company and out. From agencies to packaging engineers, there are a lot of people who touch and influence how a brand comes to life. Marketers often put together guidelines to codify the rules of the brand. When done well, Brand Guidelines are a rally cry that can inspire the extended team’s best work. When done poorly, Brand Guidelines are a wet blanket […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
The design community has been in a tizzy since Marissa Mayer shared the shallow design process that led to the new Yahoo logo. Over a weekend, Marissa personally rolled up her sleeves to micromanage the logo design with a small team. The whole approach was pilloried by a number of designers, including a very funny piece from Oliver Reichenstein: “Logo, Bullshit & Co., Inc.” He included the anecdote of Marissa’s decision to poll Yahoo employees on what should go into the logo. “Design by polling. Great idea! Next she should try the same with Yahoo’s server architecture. Ask everyone about […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
A packaging redesign is often the first lever that marketers pull when they are either new to a brand or facing a marketing challenge. If all else fails, redesign the packaging and slap a “New Look. Same Great Taste” burst on it. From my time at method, I learned that packaging design, when done well, can be the best media vehicle a brand has. We thought of cutting steel (for a packaging mold) as a media expense. But a packaging redesign is not a magic bullet. And the process is often heavy on politics and light on impact. It is […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
Our brands are increasingly brought to life by others out of our direct control. Innocent Drinks describes its brand as composed of “thousands of nice little touches”. It can be tough to synchronize the brand so that it feels consistent at every touchpoint. Many brands create strict guidelines to keep everyone in check: a style guide, visual standards, identity manuals, etc. While useful and inspiring if done well, brand guidelines can easily devolve into command-and-control compliance if taken too far. I came across an interesting Fast Company article on the “creative straightjackets” of many brand guidelines: “Anyone who’s ever written […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
Design thinking is regularly talked about in business, but design is often relegated to a supporting role. Two years ago, I spent a couple days at IDEO, seeing their approach to design thinking first hand. IDEO pioneered much of what the business world knows about design thinking. IDEO calls it human-centered design. In contrast, many organizations follow heritage-centered design. I once attended a brainstorm for a 120-year-old brand of baking flour. We had a room of talented cross-functional thinkers, but every idea we came up with was declared off limits. We couldn’t create new SKUs, change the packaging, change the […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
The experience of opening the box is just as much a part of marketing as the graphics on the box. Apple knows this, as we appreciate whenever we open a new iPhone or Mac. Opening the box is our first introduction to the product and Apple thinks through every detail of that process. I recently bought a printer that reminded me that the box opening experience is often overlooked. I spent a full hour trying to get a new printer to work on my network. The startup guide didn’t help, so I googled the problem and found dozens of posts […]
It can be tempting to push for consensus from a wide team in a creative project. Yet in design, consensus makes no one happy. TechCrunch founder Michael Arrington shared this perspective: “There’s a saying I love: “a camel is a horse designed by committee.” A variation is “a Volvo is a Porsche designed by committee.” When there are too many cooks in the kitchen all you get is a mess. And when too many people have product input, you’ve got lots of features but no soul.” Democracies don’t work in product development. Neither do unhappy compromises or peace treaties. We […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
Creative briefs may be brief, but often they aren’t very creative. Rupal Parekh wrote an AdAge article on poor creative briefs last week: “Marketers, Quit Blaming Your Agency — It’s Your Brief at Fault”. It includes this illustrative quote from Casey Jones: “If you rated the industry on a scale from one to 10, with one being a horrifying piece of direction and 10 being optimal, I would say that companies are currently somewhere between a two or three. The norm is partial, incomplete and sometimes no brief at all. A phone call or a text message comes across to […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
Working at method has taught me that package design is the single most important part of your marketing plan. Founder Eric Ryan likes to say that he views cutting steel as a marketing expense. Once a consumer told me that he buys method because the package design makes him want to lick the bottles. Remarkable design, whether in the store or in the consumer’s hand, makes every other aspect of marketing possible. Zero advertising on a remarkable product trumps heavy advertising on a mediocre product. Remarkable design implies that it’s fundamentally different from what is already on the shelf. That’s […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
My friend Adam at method asked if I could contribute a cartoon to a post he wrote for TreeHugger this week called “For design to create change, we must all become designers.” When talking about the post, he introduced me to the concept of “Silent Design”, an expression coined in the late 80’s by Peter Gorb and Angela Dumas in a London Business School paper: “A great deal of design activity goes on in organizations which is not called design. It is carried out by individuals who are not called designers and who would not consider themselves to be designers. […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
I stumbled across a great maxim recently: “a camel is a horse designed by committee.” It reminded me of this great spoof video from 2006 that imagines the packaging that would have resulted if Microsoft had launched the iPod instead of Apple. What is most remarkable about this video is that Microsoft eventually confessed that Microsoft’s own packaging department created it: “It was an internal-only video clip commissioned by our packaging [team] to humorously highlight the challenges we have faced RE: packaging and to educate marketers here about the pitfalls of packaging/branding.” The video picked up such viral momentum, I […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
I always struggle with giving creative feedback. I can only imagine what’s it’s like to be a creative director and have your work (which is inherently personal) continually critiqued in front of you. I guess you learn to grow really thick skin (or plug your ears discretely). This last week, I gave a cartoon talk to 200 people at Unilever, and it was surreal to flip through my cartoons on a jumbo screen waiting for the audience to get the joke and start laughing. Usually, I send out my cartoons alone and I’m not there when people get them. So, […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.