• 0

Marketoonist | Tom Fishburne

Marketoonist is the thought bubble of Tom Fishburne. Marketing cartoons, content marketing with a sense of humor, keynote speaking.

  • Campaigns
  • Speaking
  • About
  • Cartoons
  • Contact
  • Book
  • 0

designing by committee

October 29, 2017 6 Comments

  • Paid licensing options include high resolution download.
  • Presentation $35.00 Add to Cart
  • Newsletter or Website $100.00 Add to Cart
  • Corporate Blog/Sponsored Post $50.00 Add to Cart
  • Looking for other licensing options? click here
  • View Cart
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)

Sir Alec Issigonis, designer of the original Mini in 1959, famously said, “a camel is a horse designed by committee.”

The Mini became one of the most successful cars of all time. Sir Alec was knighted is 1969 because of its success. The car was voted the second most influential car of the 20th century. The Mini became an icon largely because it didn’t fall prey to design by committee.

Alex Issigonis wanted to create a small, simple, and economical car. He set size and fuel efficiency as the unwavering design criteria. The Mini featured a revolutionary front wheel drive that allowed 80% of the floor space to be used for passengers and luggage. The car that rolled off production lines stayed true to that vision.

Contrast the Mini with the Pontiac Aztek, launched by General Motors in 2000, and commonly cited as one of the worst automobiles ever produced.

Your Ad Ignored Here
"If marketing kept a diary, this would be it."
- Ann Handley, Chief Content Officer of MarketingProfs
Order Now

The Aztek was loved as a concept car — one of the first crossover SUVs with attributes of a truck and a passenger car. And yet, as one executive said, “by the time it was done, it came out as this horrible, least-common-denominator vehicle where everyone said, ‘How could you put that on the road?'”

A Time article reported in a post mortem, “In later interviews with GM designers, it emerged that the Aztek design had been fiddled with, fussed over, cost-shaved and otherwise compromised until the tough, cool-looking concept had been reduced to a bulky, plastic-clad mess. A classic case of losing the plot.”

In any design work, the path of least resistance is for an idea to devolve into a Pontiac Aztek. We have to fight for an idea to become a Mini.

I think much of the problem originates with how we think about collaboration. We confuse collaboration with consensus. Collaboration is essential, but that doesn’t mean the all roles should be equally weighted. When I worked at Method Products, we had a design philosophy that helped: “Everyone has a voice. Not everyone has a vote.”

Ryan Thomas Riddle and Marcin Treder of UXPin wrote an excellent 99U article on “how you can avoid design by committee while maintaining a collaborative design process”. They write:

“Committee design is not collaborative. It’s a dictatorship of many, and you’ll be reduced to implementer rather than facilitator.”

Here are a few related cartoons I’ve drawn over the years.

“Make the Logo Bigger“ August 2010

“The Power of Polarization“ July 2015

“8 Types of Bad Creative Critics“ November 2006

Filed Under: design, innovation

Get a new marketoon each week:

Previous Post Next Post

New Book Launch and 15 Years of Marketoons

the future of advertising

Browse similar cartoons in: design, innovation

Browse By Category See All Marketoons

6 Comments

Join the Discussion
  1. Dave S says

    October 30, 2017 at 7:14 am

    Great way to start the week Tom!
    As Product Manager, your message resonates deeply with me. It is important to know what problem we are trying to solve and for whom. The minute we lose focus, the product drifts.

    Reply
  2. Alex says

    October 30, 2017 at 9:43 am

    all of the kinks have been worked out…now we have,……… NOTHING!

    Reply
  3. Heidi Cohen says

    October 30, 2017 at 12:02 pm

    Tom–Love the Halloween spirit. When I was at The Economist, they called the results of a group collaboration “A Zebra”. Happy marketing, Heidi Cohen – Actionable Marketing Guide

    Reply
  4. Dan Greenberg says

    October 31, 2017 at 5:28 am

    The Aztek is distinctive! It’s iconic!

    Of course, being distinguished as the icon of truly awful design is not a positive… but I guess you can’t have it all!

    Reply
  5. Grant Cummings says

    October 31, 2017 at 9:57 am

    So true, watered down to nothing

    Reply
  6. Mary Ann Maggiore says

    November 1, 2017 at 6:36 am

    “Everyone has a voice. Not everyone has a vote.” Thank you, Tom this am excellent mantra. I will take it into my work life immediately. I wish I had this guiding phrase ten years ago when I was on a team that forbade it. And disaster followed.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Paid licensing options include high resolution download.
  • Presentation $35.00 Add to Cart
  • Newsletter or Website $100.00 Add to Cart
  • Corporate Blog/Sponsored Post $50.00 Add to Cart
  • Looking for other licensing options? click here
  • View Cart
Your Ad Ignored Here Book Image

15 years of Marketoonist compiled for your marketing pleasure.

Order Now

About Marketoonist

tom_image

Marketoonist is the thought bubble of Tom Fishburne a career marketer and cartoonist. Learn More...

Subscribe

Get a new marketoon delivered to your inbox each week.

 

Browse Blog Posts

Most Popular Cartoons Browse Categories

Marketoon Campaigns

contentmarketing

Content marketing with a sense of humor.

Learn More

Keynote Speaking

speakingworkshops

Insightful, funny, and visual keynote talks and workshops.

Book Tom to Speak

Search Blog Posts

Interested? Let’s Talk!

Marketoons

Browse Categories

Get New Cartoons Weekly

About Marketoonist

Tom Fishburne is the Founder and CEO of Marketoonist, a content marketing studio that helps businesses reach their audiences with cartoons.

© 2023 Marketoonist