Most Popular Cartoons

The most loved Marketoonist cartoons since 2002, from AI hype and the innovation funnel to the CMO role.

Lifecycle of Innovation

Lifecycle of Innovation Marketoonist cartoon

I drew this week’s cartoon thinking about two common innovation pitfalls: feature creep and over-serving the market. A company starts by meeting a customer need. Then it adds features to chase more profitable customers upmarket. Eventually it outstrips what the average customer needs or wants to pay for. A low-end disruptor comes along, and customers switch. Zoom is a classic case in point. When it launched, it disrupted bloated enterprise incumbents like Skype for Business or Cisco Webex. But Zoom has since become the bloated incumbent, rebranding as an “AI-first work platform” with an AI Companion, meeting summaries, and other […]

Gut Feel Decision Making

Gut Feel Decision Making cartoon

As an HBS student, I was once assigned to be the handler of founding Netscape CEO Jim Barksdale for the afternoon at a school tech conference. Jim was particularly well-known for his “Barksdaleisms” — his colorful proverbs on how to run a business. One of the Barksdaleisms that I always liked: “If we have data, let’s look at data. If all we have are opinions, let’s go with mine.” What I’ve come to learn is that even when there’s plenty of data, oftentimes we still go with opinions, particularly the opinions of the most senior person in the room. This […]

The AI Scarlet Letter

The AI Scarlet Letter Marketoonist carotoon

This cartoon was partly inspired by the whiplash approach to AI writing at LinkedIn. A few years ago, they indiscriminately pushed AI tools, offering to draft a full post after typing just 30 words. Surprise, surprise, this resulted in a lot of AI slop on the platform. A recent study from Pangram Labs claims that 41% of long-form posts on LinkedIn were entirely AI-generated, the highest share of any social network. Last week, Patrick Coffee in the WSJ chronicled LinkedIn’s attempts to course-correct, including retiring their “enhance your post” tool and adding a “seems like AI slop” reporting button. We’ve […]

Product Design and Conway’s Law

Product Design and Conway's Law Marketoonist cartoon

I heard somewhere years ago that the reason the classic TV remote control is so ridiculously complicated is that each button has its own product manager, lobbying hard for the features of that button. I think of that every time I stay in an Airbnb and can’t figure out how to turn on the TV. It inspired this cartoon. In 1967, a computer scientist named Melvin Conway introduced an idea that explains this phenomenon and system design in general. It eventually became known as Conway’s Law. In a piece titled “How Do Committees Invent?”, Conway observed that systems end up […]

Join 50,000 others and get a new marketoon and my insights delivered to your inbox weekly.

The signup form could not load. Subscribe here instead.

Just Circling Back

Just Circling Back Marketoonist cartoon

Former ad copywriter and Gaping Void cartoonist Hugh MacLeod once wrote, “If you talked to people the way advertising talked to people, they’d punch you in the face.” It’s not just advertising that can be off-putting. The way businesses talk in lead generation is generally worse, partly because there’s the illusion of personalization. AI and personalization tech have made it easy for just about anyone to mention a prospect’s local coffee shop, reference a detail scraped from their website, or kinda sorta get an aspect of someone’s business model. (I receive a ton of outreach calling me “Mark” because of […]

Human in the Loop

Human in the Loop cartoon

I drew this week’s cartoon inspired by some of the latest growing pains of human-AI collaboration. As AI gets more autonomous, the traditional “human in the loop” oversight model is showing strain. With pressure to “10X productivity” with fleets of AI agents, how best to keep up with the avalanche and complexity of approvals? The “human in the loop” risks becoming a tick box exercise, rather than genuine oversight. Julia Zarb, founder of Blue x Blue, recently illustrated the problem in high stakes healthcare: “Consider the busy clinician, nurse or manager asked to make a call quickly with partial context […]

Innovation Funnel

Innovation Funnel cartoon

Many organizations use some form of an innovation funnel to bring ideas to life. It starts with lots of ideas at the front end and then launches whatever survives all the way to the back end. Yet this Darwinian process of bringing ideas to life doesn’t necessarily lead to survival of the fittest ideas. By design, the innovation funnel leads to survival of the safest ideas. Organizations are good at spotting risks. As ideas run the organizational gauntlet, they can get pruned, sheared, shaped, and watered down beyond recognition. On the way, they can lose the essence of the idea. […]

Generative AI Adoption

Generative AI Adoption cartoon

I love the analogy of ChatGPT that Hubspot CTO Dharmesh Shah shared at the start of the year: “Netscape was to the Internet what ChatGPT is to Artificial Intelligence. “The Internet existed before Netscape. But the browser helped millions of mere mortals connect the dots on what could be done, and dream of what could be.” As this breakout year for generative AI unfolded, that analogy has largely come true.  Unlike some technology breakthroughs that find adoption in organizational siloes or bubble up from the bottom, generative AI has been widely accessible from the start.  Across seniority levels, functions, and […]

The CMO Role

The CMO Role cartoon

“In some organizations, just the expectations of CMOs are just so out of whack with the reality of what a CMO can really deliver on the timelines, and with the resources and with the headwinds that they have… “I think that in some organizations, you’re just being set up to fail, right?” Gartner analyst Chris Ross shared this perspective in the wake of Spencer Stuart’s annual research on the tenure of Chief Marketing Officers.   Spencer Stuart has been tracking the CMO role at the top 100 advertisers for 19 years and recently found that average CMO tenure fell to […]

Navigating AI Hype

Navigating AI Hype cartoon

My cartoon last week, “AI Written, AI Read”, has already become one of my more widely shared cartoons ever — nearly a million impressions on LinkedIn alone.  Generative AI is clearly on a lot of our minds right now. Nat Friedman, former GitHub CEO, voiced the level of hype related to Generative AI at a Jasper conference recently:  “I think this is going to rewrite civilization — Buckle up.” Various forms of AI have long been riding Gartner’s famous Technology Hype Cycle, hitting the “Peak of Inflated Expectations” before slipping into the “Trough of Disillusionment.” Eventually, the theory goes, some […]

AI Written, AI Read

AI Written, AI Read cartoon

One piece of slang that has long embodied the short attention span Internet age is TL;DR, short for “too long; didn’t read.”  With the explosion of generative AI tools, we’re rapidly entering the age of TL;DW: “too long, didn’t write.”  A January survey from Fishbowl found that 40% of nearly 12,000 workers have used ChatGPT or other AI tools at work. Nearly 70% said they did so without telling their managers. As Microsoft and Google accelerate the AI arms race in every communication tool, it will be interesting to see how workplace norms keep up.  When we all have tools […]

Evolution of Smart Products

Evolution of Smart Products cartoon

One of the most popular cartoons I ever drew was about the Internet of Things, right after Google announced the acquisition of Nest in early 2014. “I think my Nest smoke alarm is going off,” one character tells another.  “Google Adwords just pitched me a fire extinguisher and an offer for temporary housing.” iRobot later proved that truth is stranger than fiction when photos taken in homes by a beta version of its Roomba vacuum robot somehow ended up on Facebook in late 2022, including a photo of someone on the toilet. The Internet of Things has been a major […]

More with Less

More with Less cartoon

Doing “more with less” is emerging as a sort of business mantra for 2023.  Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella used the term externally and internally this week to talk about the overall business climate.  In a memo to staff announcing layoffs, he looked outward:   “As we saw customers accelerate their digital spend during the pandemic, we’re now seeing them optimize their digital spend to do more with less.” Speaking later at Davos, he looked inward: “We in the tech industry will have to get more efficient — it’s not about everyone else doing more with less, we will have to […]

AI Tidal Wave

AI Tidal Wave cartoon

On May 26, 1995, Bill Gates wrote the famous “Internet Tidal Wave” internal memo at Microsoft.  This was a huge wake-up call for the desktop software company at the time.  It immediately shifted priorities and resources for Microsoft to go after the nascent World Wide Web. I thought of this “Internet Tidal Wave” moment when I came across a helpful analogy from Hubspot CTO Dharmesh Shah a couple weeks ago: “Netscape was to the Internet what ChatGPT is to Artificial Intelligence. “The Internet existed before Netscape. But the browser helped millions of mere mortals connect the dots on what could […]

Reinventing Marketing

Reinventing Marketing cartoon

My last cartoon before the holidays was about playing it safe.  The other extreme is complete reinvention. There’s truth in Bill Gates’ classic 1996 observation: “We always overestimate the change that will occur in the next two years and underestimate the change that will occur in the next ten.” Organizations can get get stuck in a rut and resist change.  And yet we simultaneously have a tendency to overstate change, which can lead to jumping on the bandwagons of shiny new things like NFT collections, which peaked this time last year. Navigating change is a long-term constant in marketing.  I […]

By Bots, For Bots

"By Bots, For Bots" cartoon

There’s a funny conspiracy theory that the Internet secretly “died” six years ago — and is now mostly filled with bots communicating with other bots.  As Kaitlyn Tiffany wrote in the Atlantic last year: “‘Dead-internet theory’ suggests that the internet has been almost entirely taken over by artificial intelligence …  “YouTube, for a time, had such high bot traffic that some employees feared ‘the Inversion’—the point when its systems would start to see bots as authentic and humans as inauthentic.” Kaityn described Dead-internet theory as a conspiracy theory, but writes “the theory feels true.” Security company Barracuda Networks reported that […]

Decisions, Decisions

Decisions, Decisions cartoon

“If you choose not to decide, you still have made a decision,” is a truism strangely popularized both by René Descartes, the 17th century French philosopher, and Rush, the prog rock band. We can always analyze more data and write more decision trees, but we never have 100% confidence in how things are going to turn out after making a decision.  There’s always a leap of faith at some point. One my favorite “leap of faith” stories is the famous origin of Innocent Drinks.  The three founders, Richard Reed, Adam Balon, and Jon Wright, spent six months in 1998 working […]

Evolution of Marketing and 20 Years of Marketoonist

Evolution of Marketing cartoon

Last Friday marked 20 years of Marketoonist.  On October 21, 2002, I published my very first marketing cartoon, then called Brand Camp.  It was a cartoon on the 8 Types of Brand Managers. I had just started as an Associate Marketing Manager at General Mills, working on Yoplait.  I emailed this first cartoon to 35 co-workers from my cubicle on the 4th floor, linking to a newsletter sign-up.   I imagined this marketing cartoon series would be mainly for my co-workers in the office.  But I soon started hearing from people working in marketing in a wide variety of companies […]

Hybrid Work

Hybrid Work cartoon

Last week I wrote about the “messy, mushy middle” of figuring out where and how we work as more people return to the office. I closed with a funny observation from Andrew Mawson, MD of AWA: “People tried coming into the office and when they got there, they found all they were doing was being on Zoom calls.” Figuring out the balance of hybrid work is the management question of the moment.  The Corporate Research Forum found that 9 in 10 UK employers are now operating some kind of hybrid model, with two or three days in the office the […]

Chief Something Officer

Chief Marketing Officer cartoon

Unilever is the latest major company to rename the Chief Marketing Officer.  Having added the word “Digital” in 2019 as “Chief Digital and Marketing Officer”, they got rid of the word “Marketing” altogether last month to announce the role as “Chief Digital and Commercial Officer.” Announcing her new role, Unilever CDCO Connie Braams said: “And no, before you ask, we’re not dropping marketing, we’re adding sales.” These semantic twists and turns have been happening in lots of organizations, including Johnson & Johnson, Lyft, Beam Suntory, Taco Bell, and Hyatt.  Other organizations, like McDonalds and Coca-Cola, dropped the Chief Marketing Officer […]