In 2012, I drew a cartoon of a shopper emptying her purse at checkout, saying “wait, I may have a card showing my loyalty to whatever store this is.” The loyalty program arms race has only accelerated since then — partly driven by brands trying to collect more first-party data. The checkout ask for an email address or phone number has gone from awkward to aggressive. According to BCG, the average US consumer now belongs to more than 15 loyalty programs. BCG also found that as the number of loyalty programs has increased, the less engaged and loyal consumers actually […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
Conventional wisdom holds that creativity comes from “thinking outside the box”, but constraints are actually one of its key ingredients. One of Google’s principles of innovation is “creativity loves constraints,” as Marissa Mayer once recounted: “People think of creativity as this sort of unbridled thing, but engineers thrive on constraints. They love to think their way out of the little box.” The concept of thinking outside the box originated in the 70s with a psychologist named J.P. Guilford and a famous nine-dots brainteaser. J.P. drew nine dots in the shape of a square and asked study subjects to connect them […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
The Cannes Lions International Festival of Creativity has been on my bucket list ever since I started in marketing. I’m here for the first time this week thanks to System1 — who I’ve known since their Brainjuicer days. They invited me to be a Marketoonist-in-Residence for the week, so I’m going to capture some of the themes I notice as I wander the event. This is the first time that humor is a distinct award category for the Cannes Lions, so if feels like a particularly good time to be here, helping poking a little fun at marketing and advertising. […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
I stumbled across a quote recently from legendary ad agency founder Pat Fallon: “If the creative brief is not itself creative, what right do its authors have to expect anything different?” The brief is often treated as a formality or a tick-box exercise, rather than one of the most important tools in a marketer’s toolkit. A brief is frequently the opposite of brief, as an everything-but-the-kitchen-sink catch-all. The creative team is left to guess where to start and where to focus. Briefing creative work is a classic situation of “garbage in, garbage out.” I had a chance to work with […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
In 1976, Tom Waits released his classic song “Step Right Up”, a hilarious rant on the state of advertising. It’s an anthem to all the bad marketing clichés of the time with lyrics about “year-end clearances” and “50% off” messages jockeying for attention. He closes with a line that inspired this cartoon: “The large print giveth and the small print taketh away.” Advertising clutter may look and and sound a little different nearly 50 years later, but the song still captures the noise level of the attention economy. Jean-Paul Edwards, managing director at OMD Worldwide, recently observed: “We’ve passed peak […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
I’ve drawn a number of cartoons over the years on the evolving Chief Marketing Officer role, which is partly a proxy for the ever-changing job of marketing in general. Long gone are the days when CMOs were just in charge of “marketing comms” and marketing was dismissively described as “the coloring-in department.” Today’s Chief Marketing Officer role is almost impossibly deep and wide. I spoke recently with a friend trying to recruit a CMO, and was struggling to find candidates with the right depth of experience in both brand marketing AND performance marketing. Let alone all the other hats a […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
Dwight D. Eisenhower reportedly prioritized his work life by classifying tasks as important or not important, and urgent or not urgent. The resulting two-by-two graph became known as The Eisenhower Matrix and it influenced a lot of thinking in work productivity. We generally spend far too much on work that is urgent but not important. As Stephen Covey famously summarized it: “What is important is seldom urgent and what is urgent is seldom important.” Tools like Slack and Teams can help us be more productive, but it’s all in how we use them. Modern work culture prioritizes the urgent over […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
In last week’s cartoon, I parodied some of my favorite clichés in marketing presentation slides. With just six panels in that cartoon, I had to leave a lot on the cutting room floor. One of my other favorite used and abused slides is the ever-present framework, Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs. Psychologist Abraham Maslow first proposed this theory in a 1943 paper on “The Theory of Human Motivation,” where he attempted to classify the universal needs of society. Maslow’s framework is usually shown as a pyramid with the most basic needs at the bottom and higher-level needs at the top. […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
What a difference a year (or even a few months) makes. Just last January, I drew a cartoon showing a couple marketers (as legless avatars) standing in a virtual world under a banner that reads, “welcome to our brand experience in the metaverse!” One is saying to the other, “I’m sure consumers will show up ANY minute now.” The breathless excitement around all things Web3 —from NFTs to crypto to blockchain to the metaverse — is quieter now. But the Generative AI hype train is full steam ahead. From startups to marketers at large CPG companies to VC, the […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
In 2018, WSJ columnist Christopher Mims observed: “Alongside life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness, you can now add another inalienable right: two-day shipping on practically everything.” This was before Amazon Prime pushed the stakes further to one-day shipping in 2019, expanded even further this year to same-day shipping for 140 metro areas, and announced its Prime Air drone delivery test later this year in Lockeford, California. Walmart already offers drone delivery to four million customers in six states. Yesterday’s step change is today’s table stakes. When Jeff Bezos first introduced Prime in 2005, he called two-day shipping “an […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
Mastercard gave the first glimpse of the 2021 holiday shopping season last week. In their SpendingPlus report, they found holiday spending rose 8.5% over the previous year — the biggest spending increase in 17 years and higher than their expected forecast of 7.4%. They also found that e-commerce holiday sales were up a whopping 61% over the 2019 pre-pandemic level (before the explosion of 2020 online ordering) and accounted for a fifth of total retail sales. Shipping delays weren’t as bad as last year, but continue to impact customer experience. How brands and retailers navigate shipping delays will be ongoing […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
Market research firm Statista reported that the global shopping cart abandonment rate for online retailers in 2020 was 88%. This is driven by a number of factors, but friction in customer experience plays a big role. One study pegged that a quarter of people abandoned shopping carts because the checkout process was too complicated. That friction happens sometimes by design and good reasons — such as legitimate efforts to deter bots. But I think we have to continually evaluate whether the solution is worse than the problem. The CAPTCHA arms race is a case in point. Invented in 1997, […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
Rob Schwartz, CEO of TBWA\Chiat\Day, recently said: “Every client conversation I’ve had these days is about who is going to be offended by this ad. There’s a lot of discussion about risk mitigation. What that tends to do is that it makes things very bland and not effective.” It’s a tricky time to work in any form of communications. Marketers have to weigh the benefits of saying something that matters with the risks of potentially ruffling feathers. Of course there are legitimate blind spots to address, but also unintentional social media flare-ups that are much ado about nothing. If we […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
“If we have data, let’s look at data. If all we have are opinions, let’s go with mine.” Jim Barksdale famously said this as the founding CEO of Netscape in the 90s. Two decades later, we’re operating in a very different data-driven world. The question is no longer “if we have data”; it’s what data are we choosing to pay attention to. There’s a lot of bad marketing that can be justified by data, particularly data used selectively or myopically. In the realm of email marketing, for examples, open rates are the dominant metric that people look at and […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
My TED talk just went live. In October, I spoke at the TED headquarters in New York on how humor can be a vehicle to talk about things that are otherwise hard to talk about. At work, humor is often overlooked or discouraged, but it can be one of the most powerful communication tools. Humor brings people a sense of belonging, humor is disarming, and humor lets us be vulnerable. One lesson comes from Hiroki Asai, former Apple executive: “Fear kills creativity and humor is our most powerful tool to drive fear out of the system.” Big thanks to everyone […]
A couple months ago, I cartooned about customer survey fatigue and the barrage of satisfaction surveys for every minor brand interaction. Marketers sometimes forget that the survey experience is as much a part of customer experience as the customer experience they’re designed to measure. Boring, long, or pestering surveys leave a brand impression too. I recently bought a new car and was coached repeatedly by the sales rep about what surveys would be sent by the corporate office and how important a 5-star rating is to that dealership to keep low prices, blah, blah, blah. And yet, when some problems […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
Black Friday continued to take over Thanksgiving this year, expanding into a whole booming Cyber Week that set shopping records focused on mobile. According to Adobe Analytics, online shopping on Thanksgiving Day was up 28% over last year (the fastest-growing day for e-commerce sales in history). Smartphone drove a majority of the traffic (54%) and over a third of the revenue (37%). Thanksgiving day was also the first day in 2018 to gain $1 billion in sales from smartphones. Salesforce predicts that 40% of 2018’s retail revenue will happen over this long Thanksgiving weekend. Yet, in the midst of this […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
As marketing becomes increasingly data-driven, we have to be careful we’re measuring the right metrics. It’s easy to cultivate a false sense of security looking at rosy marketing dashboards that don’t actually tie to business results. I like how Lloyd Tabb, Founder and CTO of Looker, distinguishes between vanity metrics and clarity metrics. In his words: “Vanity metrics are surface-level metrics. They’re often large measures, like number of downloads, that impress others. Use them to initiate partnerships and gain a following. “Clarity metrics are operational metrics, like the number of minutes a day your product actually gets used or how […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.