I’ve drawn a lot of cartoons about the tendency of marketers to want to change everything, all at once, and all the time. There’s an old marketing truism that “marketers get tired of their advertising before consumers do.” The same instinct to change for the sake of change goes for every aspect of marketing, from logos to packaging to agencies. And yet, there’s also a tendency for marketers to get stuck in a rut and follow the same playbook over and over out of habit. This too can apply to every aspect of marketing. I recently stumbled across a […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
This cartoon was partly inspired by reading someone described as the MD of EMEA at VMLY&R, part of WPP. I’ve always found it funny that some of the most successful ad agencies have some of the least imaginative names. The alphabet soup names of many agencies are hard to tell apart, and could be easily mistaken for law firms. And yet, their job is literally to help clients manage and grow their own brands with originality and creativity. Many ad agency names are last initials of once pedigreed last names, with the notable exception of WPP (which I learned […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
The nature of the relationships between all the teams across client and agency has a direct impact on the work that comes out. Small areas often overlooked — like how much care is taken in writing briefs or how how much a gauntlet there is to run to get paid — can make a difference in marketing campaigns with the same ad spend. Agencies assign their “A” teams to brands that inspire them the most. Whether creative collaborations are treated as partnerships to develop or commodities to procure eventually comes through in the work. Marketing procurement as a discipline has […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
In 2015, the ANA surveyed advertisers and agencies to identify problems in the often dysfunctional client/agency relationship. One issue rose to the top — the creative brief. The ANA found that 58% of clients believe they do a good job with creative briefs. Yet only 27% of agencies agree (and 0% “strongly agree”). This gap in perception between those giving briefs and those receiving them is a fundamental problem in marketing communication. Creative Director Mark Duffy once described creative briefs as “the worst pieces of communications in business history.” As he put it: “Briefs serve one purpose, and one purpose only: […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
In my marketing career, I’ve worked on both sides of the client-agency relationship. I’ve experienced genuine strategic partnerships where the resulting work was greater than the sum of its parts and I’ve experienced dysfunctional alliances that were transactional and even combative. One of the biggest changes to the client-agency relationship in the last 15 years is the increasing role of marketing procurement. To keep marketing fees in check, brands started putting procurement departments in charge of the relationship. Many consumer packaged goods companies are entering a new cost-cutting wave — most famously with the “zero-based budgeting” trend driven by 3G […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
It’s an age-old decision point in marketing — work with a range of specialized agencies, or find a full-service agency that can handle everything. In the last couple years, we’ve seen an ever-expanding tick-box approach to agency services. This decision point has only gotten more complicated. In the late-90’s, I joined one of the first digital agencies in the Bay Area. We built websites, mainly for travel companies like Disney and Starwood. We were specialists and we were good at it. Then we got acquired along with 30 or so other specialist agencies and rolled-up into one big one-stop shop. […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
Considering that clients and agencies both work in communication, it’s amazing how dysfunctional they can be at communicating with each other. This is particularly clear in the creative process, from the brief to the creative review. A creative execution is only as good as the relationship between the creative partners that produce that execution. How we show up to the relationship matters. Yet too often the dynamic is adversarial and combative. Clients and agencies come to the table with different frames of reference. Clients are rooted in the business and customer experience. Agencies are rooted in the ideas. At its […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
This cartoon follows this theme of the Marketing Strategy post a couple weeks ago. Jennifer Nelson shared a comment on that post that struck a particular chord with me: “If you can’t invest the time in developing and aligning on a good brief, why should your company invest (potentially) millions of dollars in A&P to execute it?” In marketing planning, we focus carefully on ROI calculations based on previous campaign results. X media spend = Y volume lift. Yet creativity is the more overlooked part of the equation. The actual creative briefs are often given significantly less attention. Denny Haley, […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
A marketing campaign is only as strong as the strategy that drives it. Yet sometimes we treat marketing strategy as an afterthought. This often comes across in the creative brief process. Marketers copy and paste old creative briefs or parrot benefit statements without getting to the heart of why our brands or products are meaningfully unique. In an ad shoot, we often hear someone say, “we’ll fix it in post-production”. This usually happens when there’s been a mistake, but not severe enough to reshoot the scene. Yet we learn the hard way that there’s only so much that we can […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
The right client/agency fit can make all the difference in marketing. Yet the typical RFP cattle call used to make that match is broken. The hoops clients give agencies to jump through in a pitch don’t really mimic the working relationship. Agencies are also often asked to create actual campaigns for free that may never be used, all the while ignoring their real clients. “Agencies are victims of our own drama. We have taught the clients that we will give them free ideas, that we will invest extraordinarily for a chance to prove we are the right partner, we will […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
A friend told me recently that if she listened to her lawyers on a new product launch, the packaging would be blank. Marketing and legal are often the functions with the greatest friction. A legal review of an idea is akin to running the gauntlet. There is inevitably risk in any idea. Removing the risk entirely can sand the edges off the idea. Yet much of this tension is a result of how the relationship is set up. I recently talked to a brand manager for Axe (known as Lynx in Europe). Axe puts out some of the most risqué […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
Creative briefs may be brief, but often they aren’t very creative. Rupal Parekh wrote an AdAge article on poor creative briefs last week: “Marketers, Quit Blaming Your Agency — It’s Your Brief at Fault”. It includes this illustrative quote from Casey Jones: “If you rated the industry on a scale from one to 10, with one being a horrifying piece of direction and 10 being optimal, I would say that companies are currently somewhere between a two or three. The norm is partial, incomplete and sometimes no brief at all. A phone call or a text message comes across to […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
PR is called earned media for a reason. You have to earn it. If you earn it, PR can be far more valuable than paid media. But earned media follows different rules than paid media, and certainly different rules than spam. Some PR agencies forget that the “R” in PR stands for relations. They instead follow the antiquated “For Immediate Release” model (still stamped on old-school press releases). “For Immediate Release” is one-sided mass communication. It’s in the same family as spam. I cracked up at Wired Editor Mat Honan’s commentary: “Yours is a Very Bad Press Release“. In the […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
The famous Cannes Festival is adding a new category of Creative Effectiveness in 2011 “to establish a direct correlation between creativity and effectiveness … now more than ever ROI is paramount to the client.” This change touches on a long-standing grievance that clients have with ad agencies: a weak appreciation for the business results of the work. In the 1960’s advertising world of Don Draper, there was a hard line between the client and the agency. The agency delivered a creative campaign and the client worried about the P&L. This mindset has not evolved that much in the last 40 […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
It cracks me up whenever I hear a creative director referred to as “the Creative”. It makes it sound like creative directors belong to a different species. We wouldn’t refer to “the Supply” or “the Accounting”. But “the Creative” is often referred to in this strange third person (as parodied in this clever video from an agency: “Creatives grow better in the Southwest.”) I think there is a skewed sense of creativity in most business environments. When creativity is needed, we go off-site for an isolated brainstorm. Or, we pull in special people at outside agencies. It is treated as […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
Several of my agency friends have complained that client negotiations have gotten more cutthroat recently. As companies look for ways to trim expenses, many are putting agencies through the same purchasing wringer as their commodity suppliers, often using the same central purchasing team they use for things like catering and industrial bleach. While I’m sure there’s some efficiency to be found (particularly with agencies that work across many businesses within a large client), I think some of the heavy-handed tactics are short-sighted. Unlike something like soybeans, agencies vary widely in ability, talent, and potential to help ignite your business. If […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
I’ve been really fortunate to have worked mostly with Creative Directors in "The Genius" camp. But, I couldn’t resist poking a little fun at some of the other archetypes. This cartoon is a response of sorts to this other cartoon I drew a while back. And, come to think of it, my first ever Brand Camp cartoon was in this vein too.
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.