I’ve always liked this colorful expression to describe the critical, anxious inner monologue that can drive our thinking. For anyone doing creative work, the committee is a barrier. It can stymie whatever creative ideas we’re working on. It’s hard to fully mute the committee, but we can create environments that help turn the volume down. Steve Martin once said, “the conscious mind is the editor, and the subconscious mind is the writer.” In my experience, the self-editor naturally dominates, which can limit or curtail the most interesting and creative ideas. There’s a time and place for the editor, but it […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
A couple years ago, I went to the Cannes Lions, the main show for advertising. There’s a giant gallery room in the basement of the main Palais building with all the work submitted for awards. As I walked past the ads and case studies, all I could think about was how the sausage gets made. The creative “idea” usually gets all the attention and hoopla, but much of the quality of the work depends upon “process” — how the idea is brought to life. Great creative ideas plus a crappy creative process equals crappy creative work. My cartoon this week […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
In 2006, I drew one of my most popular cartoons: “The 8 Types of Bad Creative Critics.” It featured common archetypes like “The Blender”, “The Waffler” and “The Crammer.” It seemed to strike a chord because many of us have been in bad creative reviews, on either side of the client/agency table. One agency even asked to print the cartoon as a giant mural in their conference room as a sort of cautionary tale to clients. At the time, I worked on the client side, and had seen a lot of creative work go off the rails, often in how […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
Sir John Hegarty, founder of Bartle Bogle Hegarty, famously said: “Writing bad briefs is the most expensive way to write advertising.” The sentiment applies to any form of creative communication and any type of brief. How we brief creative partners is as important as the talent of those creative partners. Writing a truly great brief is a force multiplier of creativity. And yet the briefing process is very often treated as an afterthought or a tick box exercise. A couple years ago, I had a chance to collaborate with Pieter-Paul von Weiler and Matt Davies, ex-agency strategists on a mission […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
I first drew a version of this cartoon almost 10 years ago, and decided to riff on the concept with an updated version. “Make the logo bigger” is still the most common client feedback for creative work, and the quickest way to drive a creative director crazy. A web agency called New Republique once channeled their client frustration into a prank. They created an actual Chrome browser extension that makes any logo in a browser window ridiculously large. In a client meeting, as soon as you hear the inevitable feedback “make the logo bigger”, you can use the plug-in to […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
I wrote recently about lackluster creative briefs as a leading cause of lackluster creative. Another common factor is the lackluster creative review. How we run the process of reviewing creative directly impacts the result. Creative can be made stronger by the virtue of additional points of view. But we have to channel those points of view constructively. The path of least resistance in a creative project is to water everything down. I overheard a handy maxim somewhere in my career that when reviewing creative “everyone has a voice, but not everyone should have a vote.” Creative projects require an editor […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
I recently started helping out with a Stanford Business School course called “Humor: Serious Business”, which is teaching students about the power of humor in work. I came across the curriculum while researching my TED Salon talk on humor last fall, and the professors kindly invited me to be their cartoonist-in-residence. Last week, one of the lessons involved talking like a human. Very often in the workplace, we forget to talk like we actually speak in real life. Whether in emails, presentations, or any other written communication, we often to default to a stilted, buzzword-heavy, way of communicating with each […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
Marketing creative can only be as good as the creative brief that went into it. Yet creative briefs are frequently one of the more overlooked parts of the creative process. Creative briefs are often neither creative nor brief. I like how Creative Director Howard Margulies voiced this in an AdAge article a while ago: “Too often, the creative brief is joylessly “filled out” as if it were the worksheet to an IRS 1040 Schedule C. Values are plugged into fields. Facts substituted for insights. Data dumped in a hierarchical, unfiltered lump… “When you write a creative brief, you’re not filling […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
We can’t break through the clutter by adding to it. TrackMaven analyzed 50 million pieces of content in 2015 and reported that output of content per brand increased 35 percent per channel in 2015, but content engagement decreased by 17 percent. As they summarized: “This is content overload, quantified. As more content floods social networks, the slice of engagement for the average brand shrinks. With a limit to how much content can be consumed, liked, or shared, brands must create their own competitive advantages with distinguishing content.” As the concept of content marketing took hold over the past few years, […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
If last week’s cartoon was about dysfunctional creative briefs, this week’s cartoon is about dysfunctional creative reviews. Many organizations take a “too many cooks” approach when assessing creative. Everyone has an opinion, and creative communication can be subjective. If you try to accommodate everyone, you’ll end up with the lowest common denominator. I think that how we set the stage for a creative review is just as important a part of the creative process as the creative itself. The most talented creative team in the world will deliver mediocre work if you don’t carefully manage the review stage of the […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
I originally drew a version of this cartoon back in 2006 and it’s still one of my more requested and licensed. There’s an ad agency in Australia that has a wall-sized version hanging in the room where they review creative with clients. I wanted to redraw it in color and make it easier to read. I’ve seen all of these types of creative critics and I’ve been guilty of many of them myself. Learning how to give creative feedback (and how to deal with creative criticism) is one of the most important skills in marketing. A few days ago, I […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
Ad creative usually runs a gauntlet to get approved. Marketers often evaluate ads by ticking creative checklists to make sure ads are effective. But those very checklists, while intended to motivate best practices, can lead ads to become formulaic. And formulaic ads aren’t memorable. I spoke at a marketing conference in Nashville a couple weeks ago and heard the story of the first Apple iPod ad. The iPod ad that usually comes to mind is the famous one with the dancing silhouettes, but that one came later. The ad that actually introduced the iPod in 2001 was far more traditional. […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
Organizations often give mixed signals with innovation. There is a constant drumbeat to come up with the new ideas that will take a business forward. Yet, there is also resistance to change and pressure to maintain the status quo. It’s an innovation catch-22. A few years ago, I attended an innovation brainstorm that rented out a room full of beanbag chairs to illustrate how unencumbered everyone should feel in coming up with ideas. Yet, to kick off the day, an executive stepped up to a podium to lecture about everything that was off the table, which turned out to be […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
How we review creative is as valuable a part of the creative process as the creative itself. Yet the creative review is often overlooked and frequently misunderstood. The most talented designers in the world will create mediocre work if the creative review process is managed in a mediocre way. I love the video that circulated a few years ago called “Microsoft Designs the iPod Package”. In several hysterically accurate minutes, the sleek Apple packaging design devolves into a cluttered mess because of creative feedback from the Microsoft marketing team. The fascinating epilogue is that it turns out the video was […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
How Draconian are your Brand Guidelines? Many brands focus so much on maintaining consistency that they forget one of the most important goals of Brand Guidelines — inspiring creative work. Building a brand takes a village, inside the company and out. From agencies to packaging engineers, there are a lot of people who touch and influence how a brand comes to life. Marketers often put together guidelines to codify the rules of the brand. When done well, Brand Guidelines are a rally cry that can inspire the extended team’s best work. When done poorly, Brand Guidelines are a wet blanket […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
The rise of A/B testing has transformed marketing. Marketers can now instantly test and adapt messaging based on live data. A change in something as minor as the color of a call-to-action button can lead to performance improvements though the whole marketing funnel. Yet sometimes marketers follow the data blindly. Sometimes the data cart can lead the creative horse. This can cause friction in the creative process between the “Mad Men” and the “Math Men”. Google has a clever acronym for how most companies make decisions — listening to the “HiPPO” (Highest Paid Person’s Opinion). We now have data to […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
Our brands are increasingly brought to life by others out of our direct control. Innocent Drinks describes its brand as composed of “thousands of nice little touches”. It can be tough to synchronize the brand so that it feels consistent at every touchpoint. Many brands create strict guidelines to keep everyone in check: a style guide, visual standards, identity manuals, etc. While useful and inspiring if done well, brand guidelines can easily devolve into command-and-control compliance if taken too far. I came across an interesting Fast Company article on the “creative straightjackets” of many brand guidelines: “Anyone who’s ever written […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
It is a lot easier to kill an idea than to create one. Groups are often better equipped to critique than to create. I was struck by a recent NY Times article on the challenges of group creativity: “The Rise of the New Groupthink“: “Decades of research show that individuals almost always perform better than groups in both quality and quantity, and group performance gets worse as group size increases … The reasons brainstorming fails are instructive for other forms of group work too. People in groups tend to sit back and let others do the work; they instinctively mimic […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.
“All children are artists,” Pablo Picasso famously said. “The problem is how to remain an artist once he grows up.” As adults, I think we often forget how creative we are, and were. I taught a cartooning class last year to my daughter’s second grade class. When I asked the class who liked to be creative, every single kid raised their hand … enthusiastically. I was reminded of this when I taught a series of doodling workshops at the Do Lectures a couple weeks ago in Wales. Doodling is the simplest form of prototyping and idea exchange. People kept coming […]
Paid licensing options include a high-resolution download.