The AI Scarlet Letter

By

The AI Scarlet Letter Marketoonist carotoon

This cartoon was partly inspired by the whiplash approach to AI writing at LinkedIn. A few years ago, they indiscriminately pushed AI tools, offering to draft a full post after typing just 30 words.

Surprise, surprise, this resulted in a lot of AI slop on the platform. A recent study from Pangram Labs claims that 41% of long-form posts on LinkedIn were entirely AI-generated, the highest share of any social network.

Last week, Patrick Coffee in the WSJ chronicled LinkedIn’s attempts to course-correct, including retiring their “enhance your post” tool and adding a “seems like AI slop” reporting button.

We’ve swung from seeing “write with AI” pushed in just about every empty text field to “AI” becoming a new scarlet letter in writing.

In related news, Anthropic announced that Claude would start watermarking AI text in response to new EU regulation, whether the writing was written whole-cloth or even just proofed by AI.

As Shelly Palmer observed:

“We might as well just call this ‘False Positives for Everyone.’”

This coincides with a wider witch hunt to root out AI in writing, including calling out writers for errant em-dashes and other “AI tells.”

In turn, writers have responded by deliberately inserting typos and using AI tools marketed to help other AI tools sound more human.

Or as I wrote in a cartoon last year:

“People respond to content that is “AUTHENTIC,” “GENUINE,” and “HUMAN.” So let’s include those words in our AI prompts.”

Here are a few related cartoons I’ve drawn over the years:

“Tom Fishburne is the David Ogilvy of cartooning.”
— Seth Godin

Keynote Talks with Humor and Insight

Helping audiences laugh together at what gets in the way of doing our best work.

A few of the 200+ events in 30+ countries that have entrusted their audiences to Tom